Regretting You (2025)
......continues on with the influx of films based on the novels of ultra best seller Colleen Hoover...(or 'CoHo' as she's lovingly known by her multitude of readers.)
Hoover, much like Nicholas Sparks, specializes in weepy, 'all the feels' soap opera-ish dramas, brimming with heartache, pathos, redemption and all that other stuff designed to leave you tearing through a box of tissues as your tear ducts gush like open fire hydrants.
At this stage, we wouldn't hazard a guess as to whether 'Regretting You' and subsequent Hoover adaptations will suffer the same fate as did the Nicholas Sparks once prolific books-to-movies machine. (.....which finally came undone from too many Grade B-minus Sparks films dropping dead at the box office.).
The Hoover onslaught kicked off with last year's high profile "It Ends With us", which not only rang up big bucks, but now lives on forever in the endless toxic legal battles between star Blake Lively and and co-star/director Justin Baldoni.
"It Ends..." hit the bullseye with its primal concentration on domestic violence, but 'Regretting You', with its convoluted backstories, hidden secrets and thwarted romances is kind of a wandering unfocused mess.
Sisters Morgan and Jenny (Allison Williams, Willa Fitzgerald) have married their exact opposites. The quiet calm Morgan wedded boisterous party-hearty Chris (Scott Eastwood), while wild child, outgoing Jenny ended up, for some reason, with quiet, staid introvert Jonah (Dave Franco.)
Anybody care to guess who should really have ended up with whom? Easy now, don't everybody raise your hands all at once......
Born-to-be-soulmates Jenny and Chris die together in a car crash.....in the midst of carrying on a hot 'n heavy affair behind Morgan and Jonah's backs. The tragedy leaves Morgan with her and Chris's now 17 year old daughter Clara (McKenna Grace) and leaves Jonah with baby Elijah, who was actually fathered by (brace yourselves)....Chris.
And now comes an avalanche of Hoover-ian angst as Morgan and Jonah figure out their spouses' betrayal, which includes little Elijah not being Jonah's biological son. Holy heartburn, it also dawns on slow-on-the-uptake Jonah who he was truly meant to be with all these years.....
Enough drama for you? Wait! There's more, as the film tosses in the blossoming meet-cute love between Clara and struggling high school fledgling filmmaker Miller (Mason Thames.)
All these turgid soapy complications compete with each other for screen time, but a major chunk of the film devotes itself to the Clara-Miller up-and-down romance. This almost qualifies the film as officially a Young Adult drama with some adult subplots orbiting around it.
Director Josh Boone ("The Fault In Our Stars") manages the action and actors efficiently enough, but without adding much else. The film never rises above the ordinary look and feel of a made-for-TV movie and none of the cast makes much of an impression.....(unless you factor in McKenna Grace forced to spend the second half of the film in the throes of either tears or tantrums.)
Nothing much to praise or denigrate here....other than to mention it's certainly odd seeing that wonderful formidable film villain Clancy Brown ("Highlander","The Shawshank Redemption") reduced to playing the typical Hallmark movie role of a lovable old Grandpop.
Final thoughts: any more Hoover book-to-movie projects had better have more charisma and 'oomph' than this one. (Plus, here's hoping everyone involved in this got along just swell with each other, so we don't have to read about multiple lawsuits down the road.....)
2 stars (**). For the Hoover 'CoHo' fans and anyone who's got a crush on any of the cast members. Beyond that, we'd say wait'll it pops up on a streaming service you already subscribe to.